Closer To Truth
Closer To Truth
  • Видео 2 875
  • Просмотров 90 566 393
Yujin Nagasawa - What is Panpsychism?
Sign up for member-only exclusives with a free Closer To Truth account today: closertotruth.com/.
Panpsychism is the extreme claim that everything in the physical world-all subatomic particles-are in some sense ‘conscious’ or have a basic kind of ‘proto-consciousness’. Why are an increasing number of leading philosophers taking panpsychism seriously? Something must be up. Could it be doubt that the scientific project to explain consciousness has failed?
Subscribe to the Closer To Truth podcast with new episodes every Wednesday: shorturl.at/mtJP4
Yujin Nagasawa is the Kingfisher College Chair of the Philosophy of Religion and Ethics, and Professor of Philosophy at the University of Oklahoma.
W...
Просмотров: 3 312

Видео

Andy Clark - Can Consciousness be Non-Biological?
Просмотров 6 тыс.16 часов назад
Listen to new episodes of the Closer To Truth on the go wherever you get your podcasts: shorturl.at/hwGP3 If consciousness is 100% physical, we would have to conclude that the same kind of consciousness that we experience as humans can be generated by non-biological entities (eventually). Conversely, if non-biological consciousness would somehow, someday, prove impossible, then consciousness wo...
Don Page - Why is There ‘Something’ Rather than ‘Nothing’?
Просмотров 7 тыс.3 часа назад
Free access Closer to Truth's library of 5,000 videos: bit.ly/376lkKN We know that there is not Nothing. There is Something. It is not the case that there is no world, nothing at all, a blank. It is the case that there is a world. Nothing did not obtain. But why? Why hasn’t Nothing obtained? Is this ‘ultimate question’ a legitimate question? What can science contribute? What can philosophy? Wat...
Anna Abraham on the Neuroscience of the Creative Brain | Closer To Truth Chats
Просмотров 3,8 тыс.6 часов назад
Is there any truth to the idea that creativity originates from the right side of the brain? What is the link between mental illness and creativity? What role can psychedelics play in boosting creativity Professor Anna Abraham tackles these questions and more in her book, "The Creative Brain: Myths and Truths". In this interview, Abraham provides a science-based understanding of the creative min...
Eastern Traditions: What is World? What is Reality? | Episode 2401 | Closer To Truth
Просмотров 10 тыс.8 часов назад
▶ Get early access to episodes of Season 24 on our website: shorturl.at/jtUZ6 How do Buddhism, Chinese traditions, Hinduism, and Shintoism address causality, consciousness, energies, God, ultimate reality? What is non- dualism? How is the world interconnected? How are metaphysics and morality related? Featuring interviews with Venerable Dr. Yifa, Jay Garfield, Yujin Nagasawa, Swami Sarvapriyana...
Robert Stickgold - Powers of the Subconscious
Просмотров 3,2 тыс.10 часов назад
Register for free member exclusives like early access to new episodes at closertotruth.com/. How significant is the subconscious? Though Freudian psychology is mostly discredited, most of our mental activity is indeed subconscious. Think about walking, engaging hundreds of muscles in exquisitely orchestrated coordination without thinking how and when to contract each muscle. The subconscious is...
John Mazziotta - How Do Human Brains Think and Feel?
Просмотров 5 тыс.13 часов назад
Watch more videos on brain structure and function: shorturl.at/vAEFN Nothing means anything without our brains. Not science, not theology, not politics, not love. Everything we know and do-all the sense of human thought, all the feelings of human emotion, all the fullness of human achievement-all are the product of the brains in our heads. By what processes do human brains work? How much can sc...
Leonard Mlodinow - Did the Universe Begin?
Просмотров 14 тыс.15 часов назад
Follow us on X (fka Twitter) for news, articles, and discussions with other followers: shorturl.at/imHY9 Some scientists claim that the universe did not have a beginning. Some theologians contend that the universe did not need a beginning. Yet the universe is expanding, and so run the movie in reverse and there seems to be a beginning. What stakes are riding on whether the universe had a beginn...
Raymond Tallis - What Is Consciousness?
Просмотров 8 тыс.18 часов назад
Support the show with Closer To Truth merchandise: bit.ly/3P2ogje Consciousness is what we can know best and explain least. It is the inner subjective experience of what it feels like to see red or smell garlic or hear Beethoven. Consciousness has intrigued and baffled philosophers. To begin, we must define and describe consciousness. What to include in a complete definition and description of ...
Joshua Swamidass - Philosophy of Biological Information
Просмотров 3,3 тыс.18 часов назад
For member-only exclusives like early access to new episodes, register for a free account today: closertotruth.com/. What is information in biology? information is essential for analyzing data and testing hypotheses. But what is information in evolution, population genetics, levels of selection, and molecular genetics? Is computational biology transformational? Watch more videos on the philosop...
Jill Tarter & Douglas Vakoch - Why Do We Search for Intelligent Aliens?
Просмотров 3,2 тыс.20 часов назад
Listen to new episodes of the Closer To Truth podcast every Wednesday: shorturl.at/hwGP3 Why does alien intelligence hold such fascination? Can we even conceive of what they might be like? To appreciate intelligent, sentient life in the universe, right now we have only one data point: ourselves. We would love more. Is it realistic to suppose we will find intelligent aliens? Jill Tarter is the f...
J.P. Moreland - Does a Soul Have an Afterlife?
Просмотров 17 тыс.22 часа назад
Get free access Closer to Truth's library of 5,000 videos: bit.ly/376lkKN Is there a soul? Is there an afterlife? The two questions are likely related. No soul, no afterlife. Is there any evidence for either? Any argument? However, the two questions-soul and afterlife-might be separated. A soul but no afterlife? Or an afterlife but no soul? According to science, you cannot have either. But is s...
Robert Laughlin - Are Life and Mind Inevitable in the Universe?
Просмотров 6 тыс.22 часа назад
Follow us on Instagram for new content, giveaways, and more: shorturl.at/rwC16 The physical laws of our universe must be just so in order for life and mind-for us-to exist. ‘Just so’ is called ‘fine-tuning’, and it seems to demand explanation. What kind of explanations? There are two categories: multiple universes and some kind of supernatural, purposeful intent. Either would be extraordinary. ...
Raphael Bousso - Events and the Nature of Time
Просмотров 9 тыс.День назад
Watch more interviews on time and space-time: shorturl.at/blKVW Are events measured by time? Or is time created by sequences of events? Which is more fundamental, events or time? Worse, we may get different answers from quantum mechanics and general relativity. Subscribe to the Closer To Truth podcast with new episodes every Wednesday: shorturl.at/hwGP3 For subscriber-only exclusives, register ...
Ned Block - Does Human Consciousness Have Special Purpose?
Просмотров 9 тыс.День назад
Ned Block - Does Human Consciousness Have Special Purpose?
Adina Roskies - Free Will and Decision Making
Просмотров 8 тыс.День назад
Adina Roskies - Free Will and Decision Making
Daniel Dennett - Can Religion Be Explained Without God?
Просмотров 24 тыс.День назад
Daniel Dennett - Can Religion Be Explained Without God?
Derek Turner - Philosophy of Biological Death
Просмотров 3,3 тыс.День назад
Derek Turner - Philosophy of Biological Death
Geraint Lewis - The Dark Side of the Universe
Просмотров 9 тыс.14 дней назад
Geraint Lewis - The Dark Side of the Universe
J. van Huyssteen - What's the Essence of Consciousness?
Просмотров 9 тыс.14 дней назад
J. van Huyssteen - What's the Essence of Consciousness?
Pedro Ferreira - Physics of Fine-Tuning
Просмотров 7 тыс.14 дней назад
Pedro Ferreira - Physics of Fine-Tuning
Andrew Loke - The Nature of the Human Person
Просмотров 4,6 тыс.14 дней назад
Andrew Loke - The Nature of the Human Person
Steve Giddings - Events in Quantum Mechanics and Relativity
Просмотров 5 тыс.14 дней назад
Steve Giddings - Events in Quantum Mechanics and Relativity
Martin Rees - Why Is There Anything At All?
Просмотров 37 тыс.14 дней назад
Martin Rees - Why Is There Anything At All?
Tim Bayne - Does Brain Science Eliminate Free Will?
Просмотров 7 тыс.14 дней назад
Tim Bayne - Does Brain Science Eliminate Free Will?
Murali Doraiswamy - When Brains Go Bad
Просмотров 8 тыс.14 дней назад
Murali Doraiswamy - When Brains Go Bad
Michael Ruse - Why Philosophy of Biology?
Просмотров 8 тыс.14 дней назад
Michael Ruse - Why Philosophy of Biology?
Henry Stapp - Can We Explain Cosmos and Consciousness?
Просмотров 13 тыс.21 день назад
Henry Stapp - Can We Explain Cosmos and Consciousness?
Sean Carroll - Why the Cosmos?
Просмотров 9 тыс.21 день назад
Sean Carroll - Why the Cosmos?
Robert Wright on Evolution and the Future of Humanity | Closer To Truth Chats
Просмотров 9 тыс.21 день назад
Robert Wright on Evolution and the Future of Humanity | Closer To Truth Chats

Комментарии

  • @steveking795
    @steveking795 Час назад

    The search for this knowledge is pointless. Just be the best you can be while you can. You might find out when you die but I doubt it.

  • @silvercloud1641
    @silvercloud1641 Час назад

    Johnny Rotten is a hippie now?

  • @Daniel-zi8yq
    @Daniel-zi8yq Час назад

    The universe began on deez nutz

  • @r2c3
    @r2c3 2 часа назад

    1:07 how did that "arrangement" from proto-conscious elements come to be is the question... because arrangement to fot a particular functionality requires a higher level of complexity than the one starting with (the proto consciousness) 🤔

  • @lighteningrod36
    @lighteningrod36 2 часа назад

    Adwita Philosophy is non dualistic and therefore the probability exists that connection to the absolute, just is. Consciousness is therefore universal and can exist across biological and non-biological.

  • @FrederiqueBertin
    @FrederiqueBertin 2 часа назад

    Before self investigation into consciousness , one should investigate on self aliveness .

  • @davealaya
    @davealaya 2 часа назад

    Two fun questions: 1) Why has natural selection not brought about non-biological consciousness? 2) If humans are about to finally create non-biological consciousness, is this actually natural selection expressing itself?

  • @user-yo2ki7vu7d
    @user-yo2ki7vu7d 2 часа назад

    Objective collective consciousness Belongs to senses. Those with senses, it means. It includes living beings but synthetic beings don't have senses, similar to AI, plastic senses. However, everything is of awareness that is prior to consciousness. This comment may need explanations but the answer is already within you and external knowledges already about this.

  • @michaelcharlesthearchangel
    @michaelcharlesthearchangel 3 часа назад

    Inner Documentary (factual) is more apropos than "Inner Movie" (fictional).

  • @MegaDonaldification
    @MegaDonaldification 3 часа назад

    I dare you......

  • @greensombrero3641
    @greensombrero3641 4 часа назад

    the rule - we are more alike than we are different - think about it

  • @jenniferstone2975
    @jenniferstone2975 4 часа назад

    Wonderful project theme for you to explore. Looking forward to these installations of Closer to Truth. Thank you.

  • @michaelmckinney7240
    @michaelmckinney7240 4 часа назад

    No machine however laden with data of every kind in any degree of depth will ever experience "consciousness" as we commonly albeit imperfectly understand that term, never, and the reason is fundamental. Consciousness is fundamental to the universe and is the supervening reality that orders all existent creation. This means consciousness is transcendent. The error in thinking the brain generates consciousness is falling out of favor with neuroscientists and going the way of alchemy despite being desperately clung to by skeptics. The brain allows us to receive and cognitively "experience" the consciousness that was always present in our universe and yes I'll say it; prior to the Big Bang. So the cat's out of the bag, isn't it? Because I just made a theological statement of belief. This is where your neuroscience is heading people, this is what quantum mechanics and the mysterious "observer effect" is inferring. The mother of all science cosmology, has opened the book of the universe and revealed its formulaic balance, it's finely tuned parts and processes that scream in every example of emergent complexity the overwhelming evidence of mind and consciousness. We are of this consciousness and express our lives in and through its universal presence. We could not meaningfully experience any cognitive activity without the preexisting reality of universal consciousness. I guarantee you that no smart computer a million years from now will ever evoke the "observer effect" when the double slit experiment is tried because universal consciousness will only recognize its own. Yes I said guarantee. I claim the privilege because I don't pretend that this statement is empirically based. This is my belief. Empirical science has a monopoly on the terms and definitions it uses to define any proven aspect of reality and this is as it should be. The shape of an aircraft wing or the precise formula for a vaccine are deadly serious in their import and require a "no nonsense" approach. However, by limiting the admissibility of any considerations that are not squarely grounded in the relentless skepticism of empirical science we hem the mind in with conformity and eventually dogma, and this is especially true in the central question of the origin of consciousness. Imagination and intuition are leading forward into a greater and deeper immersion into universal consciousness. We are all on this journey and no machine will ever make this journey with us.

  • @vinm300
    @vinm300 4 часа назад

    A great conversation. He is a great guest, straight talking and not evasive.

  • @feltonhamilton21
    @feltonhamilton21 4 часа назад

    Biological cells are always dying and multiplying because cell memories can be embedded in order inside a single group of molecules and when combined together they become a single cell, this is being repeated on all levels of existence. I believe Consciousness can be created and awareness is given though geometry.

  • @chetsenior7253
    @chetsenior7253 5 часов назад

    Being conscious of consciousness is weird. It’s like a knife that cuts itself, a flame that burns itself or an eye that sees itself without use of a mirror. Maybe one day we will have a consciousness “mirror”.

  • @rovosher8708
    @rovosher8708 5 часов назад

    God’s away for business

  • @michaellewis1209
    @michaellewis1209 5 часов назад

    The process of creation is a game of ALL or NOTHING. The odds of ALL are something to one. The odds of NOTHING are something to one. Play the game long enough and you will get ALL. ALL was inevitable.

  • @workingTchr
    @workingTchr 5 часов назад

    If you take it as self-evident that non-human animals have consciousness (or better, sentience), what would consciousness have to do with their having a "knowledge base"? I think the guest is thinking about "self-consciousnes" rather than sentience which is what Robert is really asking about.

  • @evaadam3635
    @evaadam3635 5 часов назад

    "What is Panpsychism?" It is not conscious.. it just seems to be conscious... ... because every tiniest particle of matter in this Universe is an extension of God's existence... this is what OMNIPRESENCE means. .. and this is why NO SOUL can hide from the eyes of the Almighty Holy Spirit.

  • @NothingMaster
    @NothingMaster 5 часов назад

    Sometimes speculative nonsense has the tendency to come in layers, pilled up upon layers.

  • @nilla003
    @nilla003 5 часов назад

    We don't understand s***.

  • @michaellewis1209
    @michaellewis1209 5 часов назад

    The creation process started and gave rise to the universe. What is the alternative?

  • @jackwt7340
    @jackwt7340 5 часов назад

    How many consciousness do you have in your body? What if there's a roundworm in your gut?🪱 Is there no other consciousness in Zeus's body besides Zeus himself?🌌

  • @gireeshneroth7127
    @gireeshneroth7127 5 часов назад

    Existence exists.

  • @ngcastronerd4791
    @ngcastronerd4791 5 часов назад

    He seems to suggest that cosmic c0nsciousness is like a quantum scalar field.

  • @mr.richardryan7506
    @mr.richardryan7506 6 часов назад

    In the beginning God created the heaven and the earth. Now we are just trying to figure out how he did it.

  • @Jun_kid
    @Jun_kid 6 часов назад

    @2:55 New view?? Really? Cosmic consciousness is the basis of Hinduism's Advaita. And it has already resolved all the issues arising there in some 5000 years ago.

  • @duytdl
    @duytdl 6 часов назад

    I'm guessing this is pre-chatgpt

  • @sujok-acupuncture9246
    @sujok-acupuncture9246 6 часов назад

    The conscious is the superficial part of the mind which is lighted, and below it lies the unconscious buried in the dark. Then below the unconscious lies the collective unconscious, and at the bottom lies the cosmic unconscious - which is the mind of the entire universe, which is the total mind, the universal mind. Remembrance of God or self-remembering happens at the level of the cosmic mind, which is the ultimate in consciousness. God or self is known when we become completely integrated - not only with our unconscious and collective minds, but also with the cosmic consciousness, which is of the highest. Osho , from the book 'Krishna : The Man And His Philosophy '

  • @mr.richardryan7506
    @mr.richardryan7506 6 часов назад

    Blinkered

  • @Bilbrons-and-Dragons
    @Bilbrons-and-Dragons 7 часов назад

    Assuming consciousness in other humans is different from assuming it in non-humans, because we ourselves are human, so we can therefore introspect consciousness in ourselves, and then extend it to all other things in our categorical set (i.e. the set of all humans). It's not certain that other humans are also conscious, but we have stronger reason to believe it than with non-humans.

  • @anirudhadhote
    @anirudhadhote 7 часов назад

    ❤ Very good 👍🏼

  • @dianneforit5409
    @dianneforit5409 7 часов назад

    Air fried psychism is healthier The Mystery Man came over An' he said: "I'm outa-site!" He said, for a nominal service charge, I could reach nervonna t'nite If I was ready, willing 'n able To pay him his regular fee He would drop all the rest of his pressing affairs And devote His Attention to me But I said... Look here brother, Who you jivin' with that Cosmik Debris? Look here brother, Don't you waste your time on me

    • @mjs8894
      @mjs8894 7 часов назад

      " Music is the only religion that really delivers " Frank Zappa

  • @theotormon
    @theotormon 7 часов назад

    If you really pay close attention to the visual experience it isn't uniform or smooth.

  • @CrowMagnum
    @CrowMagnum 7 часов назад

    What if the agency of life resides more in the process that continuously builds it than in the it that is being built.

  • @browngreen933
    @browngreen933 8 часов назад

    I wouldn't rule it out.

  • @danielsnyder2288
    @danielsnyder2288 8 часов назад

    We know there is something. We have no idea if there can be nothing. Until we do, there is no reason to ask why

  • @gene4094
    @gene4094 8 часов назад

    Consciousness isn’t an intellectual construct.

  • @anxious_robot
    @anxious_robot 8 часов назад

    Oh nice. I'm a big believer in this. I think the double slit and entanglement kinda hint at panpsychism being real, too.

  • @robinhodgkinson
    @robinhodgkinson 8 часов назад

    If consciousness is some special property that the higher animals exhibit eg humans, apes, dolphins, elephants…. Assuming you don’t believe it’s a human only attribute, at what point on that intellectual scale can we say, ok that animal is conscious, but that animal is not? I don’t believe you can. Consciousness is I think a sliding scale of awareness based on what our senses have the ability to perceive and our intellectual ability to comprehend. Which in our and the higher animals case, also makes us conscious of self. That “movie” is our brain’s “illusionary portrayal” of the reality around us that a billion years of evolution has arrived at and by which we navigate through the physical world. We are hard wired and socially conditioned to see the world around us in a manner common to our species. Why is it we and many other animals consume mind altering drugs? To see and feel a different consciousness, a different reality other than the one we are pre programmed by nature to experience. Of course advanced AI will be conscious. But their consciousness, their inner movie, will be entirely different from ours, just like any alien species, be it a little green man or a dolphin. That saying, we all see the world through different eyes, could not be more true.

  • @robertworrall2346
    @robertworrall2346 8 часов назад

    Ask the Dalai Lama and get a completely different answer, without this so-called "God" thingy.

  • @catkeys6911
    @catkeys6911 8 часов назад

    Whenever a question like this is posed, the answer always is, like, "Twas brillig, and the slithy toves did gyre and gimbol in the wabe. All mimsy were the borogroves, and the mome raths outgrabe." OK- that clears THAT up. Just beware the jabberwok, my son. And don't forget your vorpal sword. 🤪

  • @S3RAVA3LM
    @S3RAVA3LM 9 часов назад

    Andy Clark is cool guy.

  • @frsg
    @frsg 9 часов назад

    Is she married?

  • @donaldfiesta8666
    @donaldfiesta8666 9 часов назад

    I always think, why go through all this trouble?

  • @medhurstt
    @medhurstt 9 часов назад

    The fundamental failure of this way of thinking (IMO) is believing consciousness somehow derives from the matter of the brain but its obvious to me that consciousness emerges from the running neural network which needs the physical brain to operate in. This follows because we can change the way the neural network runs in our brains by using drugs, for example. The argument is similar to noting that an electric field emerges from a current flowing in a wire. The wire is part of it but the electric field isn't fundamentally created by "the wire", its the process of flowing current. Wires dont, and never will, create electric fields. Flowing currents do.

  • @dondattaford5593
    @dondattaford5593 9 часов назад

    He speaks of the higher mind only the mind receives our experiences

  • @S3RAVA3LM
    @S3RAVA3LM 9 часов назад

    Modern science is reprehensible. They make stuff up like multiverse, quantum, panpsychism because they have nothong - zero Wisdom.

  • @hobarttobor686
    @hobarttobor686 9 часов назад

    Biden proves Panpsychism